Lunduke
News • Science & Tech
Myth: "HTML was invented by Tim Berners-Lee"
The truth? He copied someone else's work.
April 10, 2024
post photo preview

Go to any search engine and type in, "Who invented HTML" and you'll -- almost always -- be given the following answer (or some variation on it):

"HTML was invented by Tim Berners-Lee."

Want to know a little secret?  That is utter hogwash.

"Heresy," you proclaim!  "Everyone knows Sir Tim Berners-Lee, who was knighted by the Queen and won of the Turing Award, created the HyperText Markup Language!  You better have some serious proof to backup such an outlandish claim!"

Challenge accepted.

To start with, let's look at a simple HTML document.

HTML.  I think?  Maybe?

Oh, wait.  Hold up.  I accidentally used the wrong screenshot.  That's not HTML... that's SGML.  A totally different language used several years before HTML.

Here.  Let me post an HTML screenshot.

Or is it the other way around?

Dagnabbit!  I did it again!  This time I accidentally posted a picture showing an HTML sample next to an SGML sample!

Funny.  They look exactly the same.

What the heck is SGML?

SGML -- the Standard Generalized Markup Language (aka ISO 8879) -- was set as a standard back in 1986... 7 years before the release of the HTML 1.0 specification.

Over in Switzerland, at CERN ("Conseil européen pour la Recherche nucléaire" aka "European Organization for Nuclear Research"), Anders Berglund adopted SGML primarily for usage in formatting documentation.

Title page of the CERN SGML User's Guide

That variation on SGML -- dubbed "SGMLguid" -- remained in usage at CERN for several years.  And, in 1987, Tim Berners-Lee was hired as a contractor at CERN.

Where, wouldn't you know it, part of Tim's job was using that CERN implementation of SGML.

A few years later, HTML was born.  Just to jog your memory, here is a document marked up in both Tim's HTML 1.0... and the CERN variant of SGML.

Mic drop.

Find the difference.  I dare ya.

Now, I'm not saying that Sir Tim Berners-Lee directly copied HTML from SGML (and the implementation that Anders Berglund made of it)... wait... yes.  Yes, I am.  I am saying exactly that.

HTML is a copy.

That's not entirely fair to Sir Tim.

In defense of Sir Tim, Knight of Her Majesty the Queen, he did do more than simply make a copy of SGML when "creating" HTML.

In fact, Sir Tim made three -- very important -- changes to SGML in order to make it HTML:

  1. He added the "a href" link tag.
  2. He changed the file extension from ".sgml" to ".html".
  3. He implemented an SGML parser which only implemented a little over a dozen tags from SGML... and ignored the rest.  And called it "HTML".

While item 1 (the HREF tag) is a noteworth change over SGML, items 2 and 3 (which are very real) only serve to reinforce the fact that HTML is -- for the most part -- simply a copy of an existing SGML implementation.  And a less functional one at that.

As an example, here is the very first HTML document ever written.  Which, other than the usge of HREF, is identical to SGML.

The very first HTML document, written by Sir Tim Berners-Lee - December 3rd, 1990

Change that "href" tag to something which SGML recognizes -- such as a different "Anchor" type (which is what the "a" stands for in "a href") -- and this instantly becomes a valid SGML document.

But... HyperText!  That's important!

While the addition of a standardized way of including simple looking HyperText Anchors (aka "links" or "a href") was a welcome addition to SGML... that was, at the time, the only significant change which Sir Tim implemented in his SGML copy known as HTML.

(Other than changing the file extension to ".html", of course.  That was pretty... important.  *cough*)

Back in the late 1980s, people were adding HyperText (and linking between "documents") everywhere.  Shoot.  Apple already had a fully graphical HyperText system known as HyperCard.

HyperCard 1.0

In fact, nearly every major On-Line service of the day included some form of linking between documents.

With the HyperText hype train fully underway -- across the entire computing universe -- it was only natural that any update to -- or copy of -- SGML would include that functionality.

So... yes.  Sir Tim Berners-Lee adding "HREF" to SGML was important.  But, otherwise, HTML was little more than a direct copy of existing work.

None of this is disputed.

These are historical facts that are well documented.  Shoot.  The W3C, itself, agrees with everything I said above.

So why, then, is this important to talk about any of this?

Because the getting history right is important.

The ridiculous myth that "Tim Beners-Lee invented HTML" has been repeated, over and over again, every single day... for decades... resulting in that myth becoming accepted as gospel truth.  With awards and acclaim (and even a knighthood) showered upon Sir Tim, in part, because of that myth.

The work which Tim Berners-Lee did on that initial HTML 1.0 release was -- to put it bluntly -- trivial.  At most.  Bordering on plagiarization.

The reality is... Tim stood on the backs of giants.  He wasn't simply inspired by others... he directly copied them.  To the point where Tim's work is almost indistinguishable (see the screenshots above) from the work which he copied (and is almost always attributed to him).

Some of the giants he stood on the backs of:

  • Anders Berglund (and his work on SGMLguid at CERN).
  • Charles Goldfarb, Edward Mosher and Raymond Lorie (the original creators of GML, upon which SGML was based -- note that "GML" was named after the first letters in their last names).
  • Ted Nelson and Douglas Engelbart for their early (1960s) work on HyperText systems.
  • And so many others.

Every single one of those names contributed something new and significant to the world of HyperText and Markup Languages.  They blazed new trails.

Sir Tim copied the existing SGML, changed the file extension, removed a few features, added an anchor tag (which was a feature everyone and their dog was doing at the time), and released it.

"Modifying a Work" vs "Claiming it as Your Own"

If I were to, for example, fork the Linux kernel -- change one line of code -- and release it as "NotLinuxWinkWink"... I can do that.  It's an open source project, and I can legally make modifications and release copies.

But, if I were to then receive near universal acclaim for inventing "NotLinuxWinkWink"... that's a problem.  Legality aside, that just wouldn't be right.  Or true.

Likewise, if I were to copy the specification for the C programming language... and change one line (or add one feature)... it would not be true to say that I "invented" a new language.  I tweaked something that already existed (that somebody else built).  A little.

Thus is the case with Sir Tim and HTML.

Was Sir Tim an instrumental figure in computing?  You bet.  Does he deserve a mention in the history books because of that?  Absolutely.  And in some positive ways, at that!

But did he "invent" HTML?  Not by a long shot.

And we need to stop repeating that myth.

community logo
Join the Lunduke Community
To read more articles like this, sign up and join my community today
31
What else you may like…
Videos
Podcasts
Posts
Articles
November 19, 2024
The Pokemon Go Spying Conspiracy Theory? Yeah. It's Verified.

Pokemon Go using your phone camera to build a CIA-backed 3D Map AI system.

It sounds like an insane movie plot. But it's real.

In 2016, this was "Lunduke's crazy conspiracy theory about Pokemon Go being used to spy on everyone, backed by the CIA". Now, in 2024, Niantic Labs (the makers of Pokemon Go), proudly brags about using Pokemon Go to spy on you... and using that covertly obtained information to build a massive, 3D artificial intelligence mapping system of private spaces.

"We receive about 1 million fresh scans each week, each containing hundreds of discrete images."

In other words: Lunduke was right.

The CIA, NSA, and Pokémon Go:
https://lunduke.locals.com/post/5756204/the-cia-nsa-and-pok-mon-go

Building a Large Geospatial Model to Achieve Spatial Intelligence:
https://nianticlabs.com/news/largegeospatialmodel

00:19:04
November 19, 2024
DOJ: Google Must Sell Off Chrome

And that's only one impact of Google being officially ruled a monopoly.

00:15:13
November 18, 2024
Mozilla's "Dreams" Do Not Include Firefox ... or Even Web Browsing

A survey about Mozilla's future doesn't mention Firefox... but it does have 8 gender options.

The "What Is Your Dream for Mozilla?" Survey: https://mozillafoundation.tfaforms.net/101

00:15:34
November 22, 2023
The futility of Ad-Blockers

Ads are filling the entirety of the Web -- websites, podcasts, YouTube videos, etc. -- at an increasing rate. Prices for those ad placements are plummeting. Consumers are desperate to use ad-blockers to make the web palatable. Google (and others) are desperate to break and block ad-blockers. All of which results in... more ads and lower pay for creators.

It's a fascinatingly annoying cycle. And there's only one viable way out of it.

Looking for the Podcast RSS feed or other links? Check here:
https://lunduke.locals.com/post/4619051/lunduke-journal-link-central-tm

Give the gift of The Lunduke Journal:
https://lunduke.locals.com/post/4898317/give-the-gift-of-the-lunduke-journal

The futility of Ad-Blockers
November 21, 2023
openSUSE says "No Lunduke allowed!"

Those in power with openSUSE make it clear they will not allow me anywhere near anything related to the openSUSE project. Ever. For any reason.

Well, that settles that, then! Guess I won't be contributing to openSUSE! 🤣

Looking for the Podcast RSS feed or other links?
https://lunduke.locals.com/post/4619051/lunduke-journal-link-central-tm

Give the gift of The Lunduke Journal:
https://lunduke.locals.com/post/4898317/give-the-gift-of-the-lunduke-journal

openSUSE says "No Lunduke allowed!"
September 13, 2023
"Andreas Kling creator of Serenity OS & Ladybird Web Browser" - Lunduke’s Big Tech Show - September 13th, 2023 - Ep 044

This episode is free for all to enjoy and share.

Be sure to subscribe here at Lunduke.Locals.com to get all shows & articles (including interviews with other amazing nerds).

"Andreas Kling creator of Serenity OS & Ladybird Web Browser" - Lunduke’s Big Tech Show - September 13th, 2023 - Ep 044
November 20, 2024
Lunduke's Quest - November 20, 2024
Read full Article
November 12, 2024
post photo preview
Last week at The Lunduke Journal (Nov 3 - Nov 9, 2024)
Gimp 3.0! NOTEPAD.EXE AI! Mozilla Layoffs!

There was some interesting news this week in the world of computing.

But the only one I can think about is NOTEPAD.EXE getting Artificial Intelligence.

I mean.  What the fart?!

The Shows

The Articles

Read full Article
November 09, 2024
post photo preview
Funny Programming Pictures Part LXIII
Now with 14% more Unicode jokes!

My favorite picture this week is the one thaNO CARRIER

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Read full Article
See More
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals