Lunduke
News • Science & Tech
Access to Red Hat Linux source code restricted for the first time in 30 years
Red Hat's latest move away from Linux and Free Software
June 23, 2023
post photo preview

Back in 2019, when IBM purchased Red Hat for $34 Billion dollars (b-b-b-biiiilion!), I predicted that Red Hat would begin to distance itself from everything that had made it famous (and profitable) -- specifically, "Linux" and "Free and Open Source Software".

Red Hat quickly proved Lunduke right

Then -- right on cue, the very next year -- Red Hat canceled CentOS (the free, community supported Linux distribution based on Red Hat Enterprise Linux).

The motivation behind this move was obvious.

One of the primary reasons for the existence of CentOS was to be "binary compatible" with Red Hat Enterprise Linux.  Obviously CentOS was seen, by IBM, as possibly cutting into Red Hat sales... so it needed to die.

Was this a good business decision?  Tough to say.  But, putting the business and profitability aspects aside for a moment... it was difficult to see this massive shift in a years-long Red Hat policy as anything other than a declaration that Red Hat was moving away from their "Free Software" roots.

The CentOS community was angry about the change.  And, rather quickly, a few new "CentOS replacement" Linux distributions sprang to life (including, most notably, Rocky Linux and AlmaLinux).  Both existing far removed from the corporate control of Red Hat... but still based on the Red Hat Enterprise Linux source code (which had been made available since the dawn of time).

At the time of the death of CentOS, I made a clear statement that this was only the beginning.  That, whatever else happened to Red Hat and IBM over the coming years, we would see the Linux giant rapidly pull away from all things "Linux".

Red Hat proved Lunduke right... again

Flash forward to 2023.  Red Hat (under IBM) lays off 760 employees.  Including a number of people who worked specifically on Fedora (the community Linux distribution) and other Free Software projects.  Red Hat even eliminated the Fedora Project Manager role completely.

Once again this was -- on a practical level -- a dramatic reduction in Red Hat's investment in Linux and Free Software.

Maybe it was a good business move... or maybe it wasn't.  Regardless, Red Hat was moving away from Linux, and they weren't hiding it.

At the time of those announcements, I made a statements along the lines of: "A little birdy tells me there is more coming.  This won't be the last time we see Red Hat pulling away from Linux and Open Source this year."

Hey, Red Hat!  Stop proving Lunduke right!

Well, wouldn't ya know it, Red Hat just announced -- earlier this week -- that they will be no longer be providing the source code for Red Hat Enterprise Linux publicly.

That source code -- which was previously used by CentOS... and then the CentOS replacement distributions of Rocky Linux and AlmaLinux -- would now only be made available to paying Red Hat customers with a current subscription... and usage of that source code must be handled "in accordance with their subscription agreement".

Once again, a massive shift in Red Hat policy.  The source for Red Hat Linux (both before and after the word "Enterprise" was tacked onto it) has always been made publicly available.  This is, quite literally, a core -- dare I say fundamental -- change to how Red Hat has always worked... dating back to the 1990s.

Both AlmaLinux and Rocky Linux have issued statements regarding this change.

From the AlmaLinux statement:

"This change means that we, as builders of a RHEL clone, will now be responsible for following the licensing and agreements that are in place around Red Hat’s interfaces, in addition to following the licenses included in the software sources. Unfortunately the way we understand it today, Red Hat’s user interface agreements indicate that re-publishing sources acquired through the customer portal would be a violation of those agreements."

Obviously, this move by Red Hat was specifically designed to attempt to stop both AlmaLinux and Rocky Linux from continuing to operate.

One side note: Many in the Linux and Free Software world have objected to Red Hat placing their source code "behind a paywall".  The insinuation is that this move is a violation of the GPL.  It is not.  The only requirement to provide source code, in the GPL, is when you also provide a binary to a user.  If that binary is part of a subscription, you are under no obligation to provide the source code publicly.  In fact, Richard Stallman himself has repeatedly advocated for exactly this sort of arrangement (when it makes sense).

On the other hand...

Red Hat's subscription agreement prohibits the "re-publishing" of the source code obtained through the Red Hat Enterprise Linux subscription.  Now that is a problem.

A large majority of that source code is licensed under variations of the GPL.  Which specifically allows for re-publishing (and modification).  Which would make any attempt by Red Hat to stop any such re-publishing extremely difficult... and, quite possibly, even a violation of the GPL.

The teams at Red Hat have to know this.  Many of them are long-time industry veterans with significant experience working with the GPL.  All of which raises many questions about whether this policy was conceived by the long-term Red Hatters... or if it was mandated by executives at IBM with less experience in the area.

It's not all bad news

This may seem pretty bleak.  As if the world's largest Linux company was, in practical terms, completely turning their backs on Linux and the world of Free Software.

That said... there remains some bright spots.

As of this moment, Red Hat still funds quite a lot of development in both Fedora Linux and desktop Linux in general.  Making Red Hat one of the largest contributors to Linux-based software in the corporate world.

If Red Hat continues down their current path -- dropping long-standing support of Free and Open Source Software -- we are likely to see an increasing exodus away from the Red Hat ecosystem.  Which could mean direct benefits to the other players in the Linux world (along with opportunities to new companies who would seek to compete with Red Hat... but in a more "open" way).

So.

Will Red Hat make more moves to distance itself from Open Source and Linux over the rest of 2023?

Or will the long time Linux and Free Software advocates -- who still exist within Red Hat -- manage to "right the ship" and return Red Hat to its former glory?

I don't think we'll need to wait very long for our answer.  I have a prediction... but I'd rather not say it out loud for fear of making it come true.

Personally?  I would prefer not to be proven right again.


Copyright © 2023 by Bryan Lunduke.  All rights reserved.  The contents of this article are licensed under the terms of The Lunduke Content Usage License.

community logo
Join the Lunduke Community
To read more articles like this, sign up and join my community today
17
What else you may like…
Videos
Podcasts
Posts
Articles
November 12, 2024
Red Hat: Linux is the Past, AI is the Future

Red Hat CEO says "Al needs to be everywhere", purchases Al company.

00:11:09
November 08, 2024
Mozilla Hosts "Feminist, Decolonial, LGBTQIA+, Climate Justice using Al" Event

After laying off 30% of their staff, Mozilla Foundation flies to a Zambian resort to promote Marxism & anti-Capitalism. It is just as ridiculous and hilarious as it sounds.

00:13:13
November 08, 2024
Four Months After The NixOS "Nazi Purge"

4 Months After "Purge", NixOS Team Continues to Discriminate & Alienate Contributors.

Want to participate in NixOS discussions? First you must agree to their extreme political agenda.

00:16:29
November 22, 2023
The futility of Ad-Blockers

Ads are filling the entirety of the Web -- websites, podcasts, YouTube videos, etc. -- at an increasing rate. Prices for those ad placements are plummeting. Consumers are desperate to use ad-blockers to make the web palatable. Google (and others) are desperate to break and block ad-blockers. All of which results in... more ads and lower pay for creators.

It's a fascinatingly annoying cycle. And there's only one viable way out of it.

Looking for the Podcast RSS feed or other links? Check here:
https://lunduke.locals.com/post/4619051/lunduke-journal-link-central-tm

Give the gift of The Lunduke Journal:
https://lunduke.locals.com/post/4898317/give-the-gift-of-the-lunduke-journal

The futility of Ad-Blockers
November 21, 2023
openSUSE says "No Lunduke allowed!"

Those in power with openSUSE make it clear they will not allow me anywhere near anything related to the openSUSE project. Ever. For any reason.

Well, that settles that, then! Guess I won't be contributing to openSUSE! 🤣

Looking for the Podcast RSS feed or other links?
https://lunduke.locals.com/post/4619051/lunduke-journal-link-central-tm

Give the gift of The Lunduke Journal:
https://lunduke.locals.com/post/4898317/give-the-gift-of-the-lunduke-journal

openSUSE says "No Lunduke allowed!"
September 13, 2023
"Andreas Kling creator of Serenity OS & Ladybird Web Browser" - Lunduke’s Big Tech Show - September 13th, 2023 - Ep 044

This episode is free for all to enjoy and share.

Be sure to subscribe here at Lunduke.Locals.com to get all shows & articles (including interviews with other amazing nerds).

"Andreas Kling creator of Serenity OS & Ladybird Web Browser" - Lunduke’s Big Tech Show - September 13th, 2023 - Ep 044

👀

post photo preview
post photo preview
5 hours ago

Braxman tries to explain why the pollsters were so wrong during the last election.

In his opinion, 4% of the electorate are embracing privacy. They are hiding their opinions from spyware apps and from spyware devices.

This 4%, across all demographics, are using a privacy browser like Brave, a VPN, alias emails, independent search engines, and are avoiding offering their opinions on big tech platforms. They are paying cash and being very ordinary in public.

When I advocate for privacy, this is why. When those attempting to manipulate us don't have the data necessary to propagandize us, they can't do it effectively.

And this also reduces their ability to shape the opinions of others.

When we are private, we do something good for those around us as well.

placeholder
November 12, 2024
post photo preview
Last week at The Lunduke Journal (Nov 3 - Nov 9, 2024)
Gimp 3.0! NOTEPAD.EXE AI! Mozilla Layoffs!

There was some interesting news this week in the world of computing.

But the only one I can think about is NOTEPAD.EXE getting Artificial Intelligence.

I mean.  What the fart?!

The Shows

The Articles

Read full Article
November 09, 2024
post photo preview
Funny Programming Pictures Part LXIII
Now with 14% more Unicode jokes!

My favorite picture this week is the one thaNO CARRIER

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Read full Article
November 07, 2024
post photo preview
The Great Lunduke Journal November Fundraiser
Without The Lunduke Journal, many Tech stories would never be told. And you make that possible.

The November Fundraiser has ended -- and, thanks to all of you, was a resounding success.  Couldn't do this work without the support of each and every one of you.

Last Month at The Lunduke Journal

To give you an idea of what you're making possible, here is a simple list of the shows and articles published by The Lunduke Journal during the last month (October) alone.

It's... a lot.

The Shows

The Articles

Crazy, right?  Some of these news stories you won't find covered anywhere else.  If it weren't for The Lunduke Journal... so many stories simply would never be told.

A huge thank you to each and every supporter of The Lunduke Journal -- both new subscribers... and those of you who have been with us since the beginning.  Absolutely could not do it without you.

Read full Article
See More
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals